Court Rejects Claims By Environmental Groups That EPA Acted Arbitrarily In Approving Plan

Santa Fe – Today, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit upheld the U.S. EPA's approval of New Mexico's State Implementation Plan (SIP) addressing regional haze. The court also upheld similar plans submitted by Utah and Wyoming. The centerpiece of these plans is a joint program for reducing sulfur dioxide (SO2) emissions from power plants and other large industries that New Mexico and the other states have been implementing since 2003, achieving emissions reductions of over 30%.

The case was brought by WildEarth Guardians and other environmental groups, who alleged that EPA acted arbitrarily in approving the plans because the states had not demonstrated that the program achieved greater environmental progress than would be achieved by the application of best available retrofit technology (BART) for SO2 on a facility-by-facility basis. The court soundly rejected those claims, holding that EPA's decision was reasonable because the program covered facilities that would not be subject to BART, encompassed emissions from newly built facilities, imposed a mass-based cap on all SO2 emissions, and encouraged early reductions.

The SIP, as submitted by New Mexico in July 2011, also contained a determination of BART for nitrogen oxides (NOx) from PNM's San Juan Generating Station. EPA approved the SIP in November 2012, except for the NOx BART determination for San Juan. The resulting dispute over NOx from San Juan was later resolved through a settlement process led by Governor Martinez and negotiated by Environment Secretary (then-General Counsel) Ryan Flynn. Thus, with today's approval of the remainder of New Mexico's SIP, including the SO2 reduction program, all litigation over regional haze in New Mexico has been resolved.

Content on the Beat

WARNING: All articles and photos with a byline or photo credit are copyrighted to the author or photographer. You may not use any information found within the articles without asking permission AND giving attribution to the source. Photos can be requested and may incur a nominal fee for use personally or commercially.

Disclaimer: If you find errors in articles not written by the Beat team but sent to us from other content providers, please contact the writer, not the Beat. For example, obituaries are always provided by the funeral home or a family member. We can fix errors, but please give details on where the error is so we can find it. News releases from government and non-profit entities are posted generally without change, except for legal notices, which incur a small charge.

NOTE: If an article does not have a byline, it was written by someone not affiliated with the Beat and then sent to the Beat for posting.

Images: We have received complaints about large images blocking parts of other articles. If you encounter this problem, click on the title of the article you want to read and it will take you to that article's page, which shows only that article without any intruders. 

New Columnists: The Beat continues to bring you new columnists. And check out the old faithfuls who continue to provide content.

Newsletter: If you opt in to the Join GCB Three Times Weekly Updates option above this to the right, you will be subscribed to email notifications with links to recently posted articles.

Submitting to the Beat

Those new to providing news releases to the Beat are asked to please check out submission guidelines at https://www.grantcountybeat.com/about/submissions. They are for your information to make life easier on the readers, as well as for the editor.

Advertising: Don't forget to tell advertisers that you saw their ads on the Beat.

Classifieds: We have changed Classifieds to a simpler option. Check periodically to see if any new ones have popped up. Send your information to editor@grantcountybeat.com and we will post it as soon as we can. Instructions and prices are on the page.

Editor's Notes

It has come to this editor's attention that people are sending information to the Grant County Beat Facebook page. Please be aware that the editor does not regularly monitor the page. If you have items you want to send to the editor, please send them to editor@grantcountybeat.com. Thanks!

Here for YOU: Consider the Beat your DAILY newspaper for up-to-date information about Grant County. It's at your fingertips! One Click to Local News. Thanks for your support for and your readership of Grant County's online news source—www.grantcountybeat.com

Feel free to notify editor@grantcountybeat.com if you notice any technical problems on the site. Your convenience is my desire for the Beat.  The Beat totally appreciates its readers and subscribers!  

Compliance: Because you are an esteemed member of The Grant County Beat readership, be assured that we at the Beat continue to do everything we can to be in full compliance with GDPR and pertinent US law, so that the information you have chosen to give to us cannot be compromised.