You are here: HomeEditorial The greening of the economy

The greening of the economy

Commentary by Marita Noon

The contrast between then and now, the past and present, is startling. Sitting in the Carson Mansion, overlooking the Humboldt Bay, watching the boats bobbing in the marina, it is easy to picture what life must have been like in the heyday—1884-85—when William Carson built what has become one of the area’s most conspicuous landmarks. Now known as the Ingomar Club, the mansion is only open to members—one of whom was my host.

The conversation started with a comment about the region’s past professions: logging and fishing. “What is the leading industry today?” “Pot, I’m told.”

The answer was easy to believe.

Earlier in the day, I’d toured Arcata, California—home to Humboldt State University (HSU)—which has rightfully earned the moniker of one of the nation’s top “party schools.” Arcata also has an abundance of Victorian homes that I viewed by following a walking-tour map. Some were well maintained, but many were in disrepair with peeling paint and overgrown yards. On the self-guided tour, I passed empty store fronts and thrift shops. I saw dozens of VW buses surrounding an open garage with an aged hippie working on the one inside. A dog sniffed at my feet and then moved on, disinterested.

From one street to the next, the air was punctuated with the pungent aroma of pot. Nearing the plaza, I saw a guy holding a sign: “Out of booze and food. Every little bit helps.” A shop window featured handmade bamboo sunglasses.

Local literature describes HSU graduates this way: “Although most who graduate eventually leave the area, those remaining eventually face seeking employment in a community where the average pizza delivery driver has a four-year college degree and you can find PhD graduates working the grill at the local Carl's Jr.” I could believe it.

The December Issue of the North Coast Journal reported on the sold-out Emerald Cup held in Arcata on December 15. The event, the ninth annual—and biggest so far, is like the county fair of pot growers that boasts 202 entrants with the winner receiving a trip to Jamaica. The tent was filled with smokers browsing the vendors’ wares: “classic bongs, the latest high tech vaporizers, books on cannabis, organic hydroponic supplies and bioengineered seeds so you can grow your own.” There were also educational forums, music, and displays. The samples of the various cannabis strains are rated on looks, smell, taste, and (reportedly most important) how it makes you feel. Before the awards ceremony, a lawyer received a life-time achievement award for his work in marijuana law reform.

Stand-up comic Ngaio Bealum, who proclaimed, “I’m all for cannabis,” served as an emcee/panel moderator. He called it a “growth industry.” “It makes for sustainable jobs, jobs that won’t leave the country.” The North Coast Journal featured an advertisement for an attorney with “30 years Humboldt Country Experience,” whose practice is limited to “Marijuana Defense, cultivation, sales, transportation.” Perhaps Melvin B. Pearlston has been able to earn a living off of the marijuana trade, but it appears few can.

California’s legalization of prescription pot lead to an economic boom in Humboldt County. However, as a local report states: “Eventually, the inevitable happened. Supply outpaced demand. There were more people growing pot than smoking it. This led to the exodus of many who had moved to the area to stake their claim to Humboldt's green gold, as the price of pot plummeted to levels at which it simply was no longer profitable to keep growing indoors. As a result, there are less rich pot farmers around to spend money at local stores, pay local property taxes, and generally inject income into the local economy. Since the still federally-illegal pot industry accounts for as much as 25% of Humboldt County's economy, local businesses and governments were certain to suffer. The result? Higher unemployment. Less sales tax revenue. Layoffs. General economic disaster.”

There is talk of trying to boost the local economy by maximizing the natural harbor of Humboldt Bay—after all, as my host told me, Oakland Harbor is full. However as an editorial in the local daily newspaper, the Times-Standard, on the day of my visit, December 27, 2012, points out: “A successful port requires many things including a source of outgoing cargo, a market for incoming cargo, a transportation net to move cargo to or from elsewhere…” The author states: “There is no rail system from here to anywhere”—though there used to be rail service. Highway 101, which goes through Eureka and Arcata—the area’s two most populated cities—isn’t able to handle the kind of truck traffic needed to support a modern port facility. My host told me there is virtually no commercial airline service. There used to be flights to Seattle, Los Angeles, and Denver. Now there are only expensive and infrequent “puddle jumper” flights to San Francisco.

What happened to the planes and trains that used to service Humboldt County? According to the Times-Standard: “The Railroad served the one, and only one, commodity, redwood. That commodity is now long gone, and in the view of the many cries for preservation from the tree-huggers, probably never to return.”

My host told me that efforts from green groups like the Sierra Club and the Center for Biological Diversity were responsible for the near-death of the industry that allowed for a thriving logging-based economy. In 2007, the Times-Standard said: “There can be no denying that California forestry regulations, among the most strict in the world, have had a chilling effect on the industry. Most insiders go further than that, insisting that regulation has placed the industry's very future in jeopardy.”

I was told horror stories that amount to multi-year harassment by both state and federal agencies that have attempted to put the forest-products industry out of business. The tales would make a magnificent movie in the drama/thriller genre. But, unfortunately, they are not fiction. They are our governments shutting down profitable businesses that provide stable, high-paying employment—in favor of “green,” such as the pot industry highlighted at the Emerald Cup. 

The stories I heard in Humboldt, echoed those told in Eastern Kentucky where government policy has moved thousands of hard-working coal miners on to the unemployment role in favor of a few jobs in the government-subsidized green energy industries that provide ineffective, inefficient, and uneconomical electricity. Or, the case histories involving rogue regulators, such as Al Armendariz, who make a practice of “crucifying” the oil-and-gas industry.

How is it that America has come to a place where real job creators are being shut down, or run out of town—often to other countries—in favor of a so-called “green economy,” while pot has been legalized in California, Colorado, and Washington and heralded as a “growth industry?”

The contrast is stark. An economy that supports rail, commercial air travel, well-maintained roads, and the good-paying jobs that the Carson Mansion represents. Or, an economy dominated by “green,” with crumbling towns, burger flippers with PhD’s, old VW buses, panhandlers begging for booze, and aging hippies who now, maybe, really need medicinal marijuana for their lumbago—or whatever else ails them. Arcata shows what actually happens when “green” takes over—as it has been doing to the American economy.

It is not the environmental utopia we’ve been promised. It never could have been; it never can be. In Eastern Kentucky and other mining areas you see bumper stickers that say "if it can’t be grown, it has to be mined”—a testimony to the fact that everything comes from somewhere and something. Ultimately, that something that is used to make everything is either a commodity from a mine or an agricultural product from a farm. Energy and labor is applied to that product and another product emerges and value is added. Wealth does not just appear, it is created, and in the course of being created, it creates jobs, and families, and communities, and states and nations. Such as it always has been, and such will it always be.

Unless the population wakes up to this inevitability, we are destined for destruction. Unless we shake ourselves out of our green-induced stupor, we can expect to be standing on the side of the road with a sign, asking China to rescue us. And when they do, we can be sure, they will rape the redwoods, reopen the rails, and extract the elements that we have so sacrificially saved for them. In doing so, they will enslave our people and enrich their people and their government. In another time we called it colonialism. What will we call it when it happens to us?

Perhaps we can wake up and choose the path we know works to create new wealth, good-paying jobs, families, communities, and states that will help fill the federal coffers for the good of all. Maybe that's the solution to our cliff issue.

The author of Energy Freedom, Marita Noon serves as the executive director for Energy Makes America Great Inc. and the companion educational organization, the Citizens’ Alliance for Responsible Energy (CARE). Together they work to educate the public and influence policy makers regarding energy, its role in freedom, and the American way of life. Combining energy, news, politics, and, the environment through public events, speaking engagements, and media, the organizations’ combined efforts serve as America’s voice for energy.

Join GCB Three Times Weekly Updates

Welcome to Three Times Weekly Updates! You will be subscribed to email notifications with links to recently posted articles.
You can unsubscribe anytime. We never share or rent your email to anyone.

Fire Alerts

Editor's Note

Twice lately, someone has used one of MY photos, TAKEN by ME, without attribution or payment to me or the Beat. Remember that ALL PHOTOS ON THE SITE ARE COPYRIGHTED BY THE PHOTOGRAPHER. All content is also automatically copyrighted to the creator, when it is posted. 

For all you non-profits out there who hold regular fundraisers and want to thank your supporters, the Beat has a new flat rate of $20 plus GRT for Thank You Ads, which are posted under Community. Thanks for supporting the Beat.

The Beat is very pleased and excited to announce that it has an intern, Alexis Rico, who is studying journalism at New Mexico State University. Please welcome her. We will be experimenting together on some new ways to provide the news to you. We look forward to your comments to This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it. .

Thanks for being a Beat reader!

The Beat thanks all of you who have become friends of the Beat by sponsoring pages.

We have added a new category under Sponsors on the menu—Local businesses. You and your business can benefit from the exposure by contacting the Beat at This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it. . Someone will contact you for an interview and to take photos. The cost for the sponsorship is $100, and you can continue the relationship by advertising your business for a longer term. The longer the term, the better the discount you receive.

The Beat is now posting legal notices for area governmental agencies. Check under the menu item Community to find Legals for what's happening in the area in the way of meetings and other legal notices.

You may have noticed a blue button on the upper left side of most pages. It says Sponsor GCBTo help defray ever-increasing costs of the Beat and to prevent the requirement for paid subscriptions, the Beat is asking you to choose an amount you want to pay on a one-time or regular basis to SPONSOR a page or feature that you rely on. 

If you subscribe to the Join GCB Three Times Weekly Updates option on the left side of this page, you will be subscribed to email notifications with links to recently posted articles.

Comics are now available. As the editor, I chose my favorites first--B.C. and Wizard of Id. The Beat is seeking sponsors for these comics and for your favorites, too. Contact This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.  for rates. 

Check Out Classifieds.

It's really easy to check to see if there's a classified ad. Just click on Classifieds in the blue menu and the page will open letting you know if there is a classified ad. Remember that your buying classified ads gives you a wide readership, as well as supporting the Beat.

Post YOURS for quick results!

Consider the Beat your DAILY newspaper for up-to-date information about Grant County. It's at your fingertips! One Click to Local News.

Thanks for your support for and your readership of Grant County's online news source—www.grantcountybeat.com.

Go to top