By Jason Weiland

Fee approved despite residents' concerns over costs and services - 11-17-2026 work session and 11-19-2026 regular meeting

Grant County commissioners unanimously approved a $26 monthly solid waste fee, plus applicable tax, during their Nov. 19, 2026, regular meeting, following a public hearing in which residents questioned the increase, the county's billing practices and the possibility of paying additional landfill charges on top of private trash collection fees.

The new base rate, approved through Resolution R-26-60 for fiscal year 2027, amounts to $312 annually before tax, compared with the previous charge of approximately $63 a year.

Several residents asked commissioners to reconsider the increase or find ways to reduce its impact, particularly on people living on fixed incomes. Commissioners acknowledged those concerns but said the Southwest Solid Waste Authority needed additional revenue to maintain operations and meet its financial obligations.

The decision followed the commission's Nov. 17 work session, when officials reviewed the agenda for the upcoming regular meeting and discussed which version of the county's solid waste ordinance should accompany the proposed fee resolution. During that work session, District 3 Commissioner Nancy Stephens pointed out that an older version of the ordinance had been included in the meeting materials. "I was able to go back to September 24th, which is the meeting where we have the final solid waste ordinance in that packet," Stephens said. "And that's the one we need to include."

She explained that the earlier version contained three waiver exceptions, while the final ordinance adopted in September included different language addressing occasional and uninhabited use, as well as brush and composting activities. That distinction became important two days later when a resident questioned why she was being billed for an unoccupied mobile home.

The issue first came up during the general public input portion of the Nov. 19 meeting, when Buckhorn resident Lewis Mitchell questioned the reduction in the amount of waste residents could bring to the landfill without additional charges. Mitchell discussed the practical difficulties of maintaining rural properties, including the disposal of manure from his horse corral, and questioned whether the 500-pound allowance was sufficient for residents dealing with accumulated waste.

He also raised concerns about charges for uncovered loads and aspects of the landfill's operating arrangements. Mitchell said he understood that operating costs could require additional revenue, but he wanted the authority to examine how its policies affected residents. He thanked Stephens for discussing the matter with him and correcting some of his earlier misunderstandings.

Commission Chairman Chris Ponce, who represents District 1, reminded residents that a formal public hearing on the proposed fee would take place later in the meeting. "If you have public input on the waste fees and all that, it would probably be better if you do it during testimony in our public hearing." He explained that the testimony would become part of the official record.

During the public hearing, Patty Merier says, "…my concern about the public waste is, I get two bills. I have two mobile homes on one property. One was my father-in-law's. He is now deceased. It is empty." She was keeping the second home available in hopes that family members might eventually move there and help her as she grew older. "But I get two bills, and if it goes up higher, if it goes to $30 a month, it'll be 60 times 12 is $720 a year, which I'm on a fixed income. I just don't know why I'm getting two bills, and it's just my husband and I."

Merier said she had previously emailed county officials about the situation without receiving a response. Ponce told her the county manager would contact her.

The question returned during the commissioners' discussion after the public hearing. "In ordinance 026-02, there is a provision in that ordinance that has already been passed for a person in that situation to come to the county and request a waiver for that other bill," District 5 Commissioner Tom Shelley said. "So we have addressed that question and that can be resolved."

The exchange illustrated why Stephens had emphasized using the final adopted ordinance during the Nov. 17 work session. Although the county had established a waiver process, Merier had not received an answer about her particular situation.

Nancy August, who identified herself as a resident of the Wind Canyon subdivision west of Silver City, said she learned of the proposed increase about a week before the hearing when she paid her quarterly solid waste bill. "When I learned this a week ago, my husband and I had no knowledge of a rate increase, and I was told it was advertised in social media, which we don't do, thankfully, and the Silver City Press, which we do not get," August said. "A simple cheap postcard sent out to everybody that pays this would have been good."

August also questioned whether the same fee was appropriate for households that generate very different amounts of waste. "My husband and I generate about six bags quarterly," she said. "We recycle everything. We compost. We have very little, very little trash."

She told commissioners that a neighbor, who was active in the community and used social media, also had not known about the proposal. "I am asking that it be postponed until a reasonable public input can be put in. Reject it until more public input and notification can be put forward for this. It is an exorbitant rate increase."

The commission did not postpone the resolution.

Michael Ford, who said he and his wife own and operate Gila Sanitation, told commissioners the company serves more than 700 stops in unincorporated Grant County, including more than 600 rural households, as well as businesses, schools and other facilities. Many of those customers are elderly or disabled and depend on curbside collection because they cannot easily transport their own trash, he said. "Historically, the county gave Gila Sanitation a tonnage credit at the landfill when our customers paid the county solid waste fee," Ford said. "Because of that credit, we have never had to pass landfill tonnage charges onto customers."

Ford said the loss of that credit could force the company to pass along the authority's $85-per-ton tipping charge. "That means a senior citizen on fixed income outside of city limits ends up paying the full county solid waste fee plus our curbside service rate and now possibly landfill tonnage, paying twice for the same exact disposal. For elderly and disabled residents who physically cannot haul their own trash to the transfer station, that double hit forces them to cancel pickup."

Ford warned that customers canceling private collection could increase demand at transfer stations and contribute to illegal dumping. He offered a way for the county to verify which residents were already paying for private service. "We are ready to provide the county with a verified quarterly service roster for active rural accounts or standardized proof-of-service receipts," Ford said. He asked officials to consider restoring the tonnage credit or establishing an exemption or credit for verified customers.

Sammy Morales, 75, said he understood the landfill's operating costs had increased but was concerned about the effect on older residents, particularly those living on fixed incomes. "A lot of people would like to come up here and talk to you, but they don't catch the gist of when the meeting's going to be, what it's going to be about," Morales said.

He told commissioners that he could afford the increase but knew former coworkers who could not. "I know that we have to pay for solid waste. I know it's increasing cost. My problem is all at once." Morales said some residents had neither the time nor the physical ability to attend meetings and express their concerns. "There has to be a different way of approaching this," he said. "If you would phase it in, perhaps they'd have time to be able to adjust their budgets for that."

He also questioned why officials had not addressed the fee sooner. "Perhaps we knew about this five years ago, we could have been talking about it and phasing it in since then," Morales said.

Following the public hearing, Stephens moved to approve Resolution R-26-60, and District 2 Commissioner Eloy Medina seconded the motion. The commission then spent approximately 35 minutes discussing the proposal before voting.

Ponce, who uses private curbside collection himself, questioned the effect on customers such as Ford's. "I am paying twice for that same bag of trash to go into that landfill. I wish that our commission would have looked at getting a list from his, I believe he said approximately 700 people, and even from Southwest, to look at this, to see other alternatives that we could have done."

Ponce also accepted responsibility for not addressing the county's fee sooner. "Not once in my eight years did I think or decide on changing those rates," he said. "That's on me. That is my fault as a chair and being chair eight years, for not looking at that." He wanted the commission to continue examining the private-hauler issue even if the fee was approved.

Tom Shelley distinguished the county's obligation to fund the Southwest Solid Waste Authority from the separate service residents purchase when they hire a private hauler. "We have no choice. We have to divvy that, or take that bill and pay it."

He explained that the county fee supports the landfill and related disposal facilities, which remain available to private-hauler customers for waste their regular collection service may not accept. Shelley recalled proposing language during earlier ordinance discussions that would have addressed customers who already paid for private collection. That proposal was not adopted. "My solution shouldn't eliminate the county bill, but it might reduce it somewhat," he said.

He supported further examination of the issue but did not advocate eliminating the county fee for every household using a private hauler.

"Solid waste is a fund where we're not supposed to make money and it's not supposed to be in deficit," Stephens told commissioners. She said the authority had financial obligations that could no longer be met under the previous fee structure. "From the public's view, everything might have seemed to be going great, but at the end of 2024, the audit for the authority showed that we had a debt load of $3.8 million."

"We can't do that. Like, we have to have a financial assurance." The authority must maintain reserves and meet environmental requirements associated with operating the landfill and eventually closing disposal cells, she explained. Those obligations had contributed to a larger operating budget.

Stephens acknowledged that officials should have adjusted the county's fee over time instead of leaving residents to face a substantial increase at once. "We've said before, you know, it's been 30 years. We should have done it gradually, but we didn't," she said. "We, as in public servants."

Stephens said authority members had committed to avoiding similar increases in the future by tying adjustments to the consumer price index. She also explained why the authority had rejected a proposal to extend tonnage allowances to private haulers serving unincorporated Grant County.

Municipalities with exclusive collection contracts, including Silver City, Santa Clara, Bayard and Hurley, receive allowances based on their arrangements with the authority. Unincorporated Grant County does not have an exclusive contract with any private hauler. "I put forward an alternative that would give a tonnage allowance to our unincorporated Grant County haulers," Stephens said. "But the problem is, I was outvoted."

The authority had not included that additional allowance in its approved financial plan. "We did not account for a tonnage allowance for unincorporated Grant County," she said. "So that… our budget would take a hit." Stephens said authority members were concerned that reducing anticipated revenue could create another deficit and force them to return to the public for additional money.

The county commission's approval of the $26 fee did not change the authority's separate policy governing private-hauler tonnage allowances.

"I've also heard the idea that the 500-pound allowance, well, it hurts because we raise rates and we're reducing the amount you can bring, right?" Stephens said. She suggested that the authority consider allowing unused portions of the allowance to carry forward. Under that proposal, someone who visited the landfill only a few times a year might be able to dispose of a larger load without an additional charge, provided the resident had not used the allowance during previous months. Stephens also suggested community brush or junk collection days, potentially organized with other agencies or supported by grant funding.

Neither proposal was discussed or approved during the meeting.

Stephens said the authority had purchased eight compactors. Five were planned for collection sites in Buckhorn, Cliff, Pinos Altos, Mimbres and Mule Creek, while the other three would replace units as they approached capacity.

She said the compactors would hold approximately four times as much waste as conventional roll-off containers, would be accessible around the clock and were expected to become operational by the end of the year. "And here's the important thing, is it won't count towards people's 500-pound allowance," Stephens said. Residents would be able to dispose of regular bagged household trash at the compactors without using the allowance available for other waste brought directly to the landfill.

Ponce objected to the absence of a planned location in Arenas Valley. "We sit up here saying, 'Oh, you have the option. You could take it to a compactor,' but Arenas Valley doesn't have one." Stephens said an additional location might still be negotiable. Ponce urged the authority to pursue the site, noting that his district was the only one without a planned compactor location.

No additional location could be approved during the meeting.

Ponce wanted more public reporting on the authority's finances and how the increased fees would be used. "I would also like for our solid waste board and our commission to put out a quarterly report of what profits this company is making on this, of what is being spent, on what our citizens are getting for all this," he said.

He also raised concerns about equipment repairs and the need to keep collection facilities operating. Ponce proposed a citizens' advisory board that could include private haulers and other residents affected by the authority's decisions.

Although he said he had generally opposed advisory boards because elected officials should make decisions themselves, he believed the solid waste system would benefit from additional public participation. "But I think in this right now we should, or this commission or the solid waste authority should, put an advisory board to get more input to see what people are feeling out there."

He also questioned the authority's voting structure. Grant County and Silver City each have two representatives, while Santa Clara, Bayard and Hurley each have one. Stephens responded that the authority had agreed at its Nov. 18 meeting to move future meetings to the county commission chambers, where members of the public would have more room and better opportunities to see and hear the proceedings.

Meetings would remain on the third Wednesday of each month at 3 p.m., and a virtual attendance link would be posted on the authority's Facebook page. "I want to be transparent. I want to improve services for solid waste and landfill management," Stephens said. "I want to hear people's ideas and concerns."

Stephens agreed to take Ponce's quarterly financial reporting request to the authority board.

Medina said the county had delayed dealing with the problem for too long. "This should have been done by public servants a long time ago," he said. "Regardless of that, we have to do it now."

He recognized that residents were already struggling with rising costs. "This is like not the right time to get this increase because everyone has had it up to here, including myself," Medina said. He warned that without sufficient revenue, the landfill could become financially unsustainable, potentially requiring the community to transport waste to facilities in Deming or Las Cruces at additional expense.

District 4 Commissioner Eddie Flores said he had considered whether the county could subsidize part of the cost. "Can we cut the fee in half and let the county pay half? But then we run out of money," Flores said. "It's just a challenge that we let go for so many years, and now we're at that crossroads."

Flores wanted officials to revisit the private-hauler issue after the new fee had been in effect for a period of time. "I think we really need to sit down and revisit" the issue, he said, explaining that officials should determine whether residents were being charged twice for the same disposal service.

He also acknowledged Morales's testimony. "Mr. Morales, I appreciate your comments," Flores said. "The comments you made, they hit hard."

Following the discussion, the commission proceeded to a roll-call vote on Resolution R-26-60. Ponce, Medina, Stephens, Flores and Shelley each voted yes, approving the $26 monthly solid waste fee, plus applicable tax, unanimously. The resolution established the county's new fee but did not change the authority's separate private-hauler policy, the 500-pound allowance or the planned compactor locations. Those matters remained open for further consideration.