By Lynn Janes
The Silver City Consolidated Schools held a work session and regular meeting October 26, 2026. Ashley Montenegro, Michelle Diaz (attended late due to work), Patrick Cohn, Mike McMillan and Kimberly Klement attended. Superintendent William Hawkins also attended.
Work session
Mark Valenzuela, Bosque Advisors, attended online to provide an update for the board on bond sales. They will be starting the bond process for the third series. This will be to provide some information to the board to let them know what place the market will be. They will attend the November board meeting to present a bond resolution to authorize them to move forward with a $5.5 to $6 million bond sale.
In September and October, they had seen the interest rates rise. In the special election voters approved $25 million in bond sales in four installments over four years. Part of the communication with the community made them aware that they had a lower debt service levy among other districts. It made the district not eligible for a reduction in match requirements. By increasing to a 10 mill levy the district could obtain more funds from the state for projects. He had a power point presentation to further illustrate the process.
Montenegro asked for clarification on the two processes he had put forward. Both would be a public bond offering in the public bond market. They could hire an underwriter for the district before entering the market or receive bids from investment banks. Both would require an underwriter, and the lowest cost would be chosen. Valenzuela continued with a comprehensive explanation of the process and had slides to further the explanation.
Work session adjourned
Regular meeting started.
The board approved the minutes from the finance meeting September 17, 2026, work session and regular meeting September 28, 2026. They also approved the agenda.
Information and presentations.
Bob Carson from Kiwanis came to present the student of the month and said this would be their 81st year in Grant County.
Dannika Moon, Cliff 9th grade, has been respectful consistently, has a strong work ethic and a commitment to positively contributing to the Cliff school community. She actively participates in numerous activities including cross country, FFA, 4-H, basketball and track.
Trinity Armendariz, La Plata Middle School 7th grade, has been kind to her classmates and teachers and treats others with respect. Even when something has been hard, she puts out the effort and does her best.
Makayla Marcial, Silver High School 12th grade, Has worked hard to achieve and maintain good grades through the years. She participates in many activities such as soccer, volunteers for concession stand, yearbook and others.
This month the school board would be recognizing staff from Harrison Schmitt. Each month they would highlight a different school. Gabrielle Begay, teacher 5 years; Paul Montes, security guard, 5 years; Amanda Chavez, library assistant, 10 years; Jennifer Sprague, teacher, 10 years; and Patricia Doherty, teacher, 15 years.
Two people had asked to present alternatives to the proposed projects for the athletic fields, Gary Stailey and Robert Goates.
Stailey thanked the board for allowing them to summarize their concerns regarding the proposal of athletic fields and the time they individually took to meet with them. The meetings had helped them better understand the district's position and formulate a respectful response. Some had asked them why they have brought up issues on an ongoing project for two years when they could have come to them sooner. Stailey said the current proposed project would be considerably different from what had been originally proposed. The bond on the ballot spoke to generally improving or purchasing school grounds and no mention of artificial turf. The facilities master plan does contain artificial turf language but not on the 2024 ballot. It had been what the voters read and passed. Stailey added that the facilities master plan speaks to the artificial turf cost to be $3 plus million and not $6 plus million. The location for the improvements lists is the current Benny Altamirano Sports Complex.
"Based upon our observations, it is our opinion that the broader public was not fully aware of the intended uses of the bond, and we believe these proposed changes are significant and they call for a transparent reassessment." Stailey added also that Silver Consolidated Schools ranks mediocre among other school districts and then added that New Mexico ranks at the very bottom of the 50 states in educational proficiency, which it has held for the past ten years in a row. Average would still be a failure when half can't read at their grade level and three quarters can't do math at the expected level. "We are falling behind." In presenting the facts he wanted to offer some solutions.
He told the board they had an opportunity to make a huge positive difference in the future of the kids. "You can choose to buy a shiny new hood ornament that glitters and glows and then gets discarded when it's no longer useful or you can choose to invest in a powerful engine that has the potential to provide students with knowledge and skills that will propel them into a bright and successful future. It is the absolute right of students, parents, families, and residents to expect and in fact demand that high level of commitment from its Board of Education."
Stailey proposed, "The Board's proposal to relocate, consolidate, and resurface athletic fields at a minimum cost of six plus million dollars, which happens to be almost 25 percent of the total 25 million dollar bond passed in 2024, we submit that that is the shiny hood ornament. It is not investing in a powerful engine that is our youth. Research clearly shows that there's no correlation between improved athletic fields and improved academic performance. There is, however, strong evidence that improving classroom environments, creating space for STEM labs, CTE, and other programs improves academic performance and enhances future career opportunities." He added artificial turf would downgrade and cheapen the facility significantly and pointed out that each board member had expressed their preference of real grass. "Grass is safer, healthier to play on and environmentally friendlier." The artificial turf must be replaced every eight to ten years and added that the New Mexico activity handbook for public schools does not mandate the offering of extracurricular activities at any level. He said they do however believe public schools should offer them at a reasonable level.
"We agree that we should offer our youth good quality sports fields, which is not fully the case currently. On the other side of the coin, schools are clearly mandated to provide education programs at their highest levels. We believe with some level of confidence, combined with a high level of will and commitment from this school board, that the district can have both quality athletic fields and enhanced opportunities for STEM, CTE, and other career programming for our kids' future at less expense than spending six plus million dollars on a large piece of plastic that must be disposed of in our landfill every eight to ten years. The district's annual budget of 35.4 million dollars combined with another 25 million dollars in the 2024 general obligation bond is a lot of money. That money, folks, ain't free." The taxpayers foot that bill. They did not believe spending $6 plus million to install artificial turf was the best decision.
In meeting with them individually they had been convinced they had already made the decision to spend the $6 plus million on the project. In spite of that he encouraged them before making the final decision to consider other alternatives which he listed that had been researched. They would rather see $1 million to $2 million to improve existing grass fields and the balance to be used on improving academic performance and career opportunities for the youth of Grant County.
Goates said he had been working with Stailey and thanked the board for meeting with them individually and together with a receptive attitude. He echoed some of the points Stailey had made and added that the decision regarding the sports fields would be theirs solely but will have broad implications for the citizens of Grant County and the town of Silver City. Given the broad implications of this decision, they have been surprised that not a lot of active discussion had taken place between all parties on the impact of the decision. It will mean the loss of the Ben Altamirano Sports Complex as a community asset and impact on the landfill when the artificial turf needs to be replaced would just be a few examples. When that artificial turf must be replaced it will mean an additional 800 to 1,000 tons of plastic in the landfill every eight to ten years. The landfill already has the addition of artificial turf from Scott Park, Cobre and Western New Mexico University fields. Goats further said their arguments made to move the fields and install artificial turf had flaws.
The district had focused heavily on the lack of land ownership and the lease terms with the state land office as reasons for the move. "We believe these concerns are overstated and could be reasonably addressed.
Desire McGee, SCEA (Silver City Education Association) had come to present to the board on behavior escalation and a district-wide intervention protocol.
McGee had been checking with the staff throughout the district. She had not heard the usual about salaries and prep time but instead frustration and fear of what to do with students acting out and the severity of aggression that has been escalating. This has not been something just here, but a nationwide survey of the National Education Association finds student behavior continuing to be a number one problem. "Kids are not inherently angry or bad. Difficult behaviors follow our students into the building from neglect, trauma, unmet mental health needs and the aftermath of a pandemic that reshaped childhood. However, left unaddressed, these behaviors create a compounding cost. Teachers and staff are exhausted and leaving the profession."
McGee said this led to instruction time lost, restraint incidents, evacuations, injured staff, substitutes, legal exposure that all come with a price. They have seen a steady rise in aggressive behaviors in the schools. Once they would have an occasional incident and now it has become a daily reality. Verbal attacks directed at both staff and students including personal threats, physical attacks, including hitting and thrown furniture, property damage when classrooms in common areas are trashed during outbursts.
She had come to ask the board to adopt a district-wide behavior intervention protocol. It would be a consistent tiered framework that trains all staff in de-escalation and offers clear reporting and response pathways. It will also route students into behavioral support and family engagement before the situation reaches a breaking point.
She asked the board to consider forming a working group of teachers, administrators, counselors and parents to research and develop what a district-wide protocol would look like and bring forward a plan. "Our students deserve classrooms that they can learn and thrive in, and our educators deserve the support to make that possible."
Information to the board
The La Plata Middle School student council had a presentation for the board. The students had interviewed other students, teachers, clubs for their ideas and listed them in their power point presentation. The school had grown by 122 students when they brought in the sixth grade and covered other statistics such as attendance 95 percent, 76 positive referrals and 54 discipline incidents. Tardiness issues had continued but had been because of the traffic adjustment problems.
The students went on to highlight the activities and events they had recently. Positive and negative issues had been listed from the last quarter along with the athletic wins and losses. They had solutions to the negative issues presented.
The board had questions about their presentation. Montenegro commented they had done very well presenting. The board continued with questions and dialogue for a while.
Hawkins had a bond project update.
Since last month he had reached out to the state land office and formally asked them to explore a short term extension, three to five years on the Benny Altamirano Sports Complex lease. They do have a meeting scheduled for October 30, 2026. The Harrison Schmitt Elementary School bus route continues to be worked on, and the roof project has started and contractors will be working on it for 289 days not taking into consideration possible weather issues. Cliff schools has been designed and in the preconstruction phase. Hawkins wanted to add the design team had been made up of Cliff employees and staff and the project has been on the scheduled timeline.
Recently at the high school they had a gas leak. In 2017 or 2018, some work had been down where the leak had been found, and they had a failure that had been small for some time but had escalated requiring attention. New Mexico Gas came in and fixed the line and state inspectors had come in and cleared the repair. Hawkins thanked several school employees for their help.
Keith Bausman, associate superintendent, had the personnel report for the board. The district is 98.8 percent fully staffed for full-time positions.
Cindy Barris, associate superintendent, had an enrollment update. They had increases, decreases and fluctuations making the number similar to the previous month. The total students enrolled at this time, 1903.
Barris updated the board on the mental health grant. She said it has been in a holding pattern and the school has funding until December 31, 2026. They also have funds from the state until the end of the year. They have still been approved for federal funding for the next two years that will cover the personnel for the program and includes two full-time and two interns. The state said they will continue to look for additional funding.
Barris provided a report on data on student achievement. The report had data for the past five years. She had a power point presentation that can be viewed through a link on the agenda available at https://meetings.boardbook.org/Public/Organization/945
Barris went over each aspect and part of the data with explanations and compared it to the state data. They had seen growth in many areas. Science had been a mixed bag due to the changes in science assessment.
The conversation switched to the SAT exams in high school. Barris said they had seen changes there as well. She said many students will take the exam more than once and do better the second time. Diaz thanked the Alicia Beck and her family volunteering their time to help students prepare for the SAT and provide rides to the classes. Barris added that the kids that study with her do better on the SAT than the ones that don't. Diaz and Barris stressed again she does this voluntarily. Many students do not know how to study and have to learn to be test takers. Diaz said, "We have to encourage our kids to take advantage of the resources they have."
Barris told the board to contact her with any questions because she had hit them with a lot of information at once.
Finance sub committee
Cohn said they had met and reviewed the salaries to the budget, with the consolidation of Sixth Street Elementary and Jose Barrios Elementary. He added that all their questions had been addressed and clarified.
Audit committee
Cohn said the audit is in progress.
Threat assessment committee
McMillan didn't know if they had a meeting and deferred to Bausman and Hawkins. Hawkins said they did have a meeting. It had been impromptu. Any time they have an incident or concern a meeting will be called. A week earlier they had a communication that had been statewide regarding a Tik Tok challenge, nationwide but had happened in Farmington. He explained it further and the image used had been happening since August and gone state to state then turned up in New Mexico the past week. The information had gone to principals, security, community and parents to monitor the students. Although the challenges may seem innocent, they can have real destructive impacts in the learning environment.
"These are terroristic threats, violations of law, felony charges. Sometimes a seventh grader or a ninth grader may not be thinking about the legal ramifications. It's a joke, it's a prank but not realizing that these jokes and pranks can have lasting impacts on their record." It was the reason Hawkins scheduled the most recent threat assessment meeting.
Board president
Montenegro did the first reading of policy advisories for commitment to religious neutrality, released time for religious instruction and limited open and closed forum. These have been made available in full to the board and they will vote for adoption the next month.
Board comments
Montenegro appreciated the dialogue around student achievements and shows it has been a priority at Silver Schools. "I don't know how many positives it takes to counter a negative, but it is quite a few." She said she knew the teachers, administrators, support staff and students have been working hard to raise the bar. The ultimate intent being educating students and preparing them for a productive feature in fields or paths of their choosing. The district has never had as many pathways as it does today.
Montenegro referred to the La Plata Middle School presentation. Sports provide a way for students to feel a sense of belonging. Students that feel like they belong will be more engaged and open to learning. As mentioned by McGee classroom challenges affect student performance. She would not pick and choose what would be important but will support investments in both educating and athletics. "Equitable is not always equal." Silver Schools will be small in comparison to the entire state and their data does not move the state data.
"I am less interested in the entire state and more interested in what Silver Schools is doing for students and I believe we are moving in the right direction." GO bonds may only be used on facilities and capital projects. "You are working hard. You guys are aligned. You have a leader. He's leading you in the direction you need to go. You're leading your teachers. You're investing in students. I don't want to hear that New Mexico is 50th because you guys are doing the work and you should be proud of it."
Diaz holds similar sentiments on what Montenegro said. "I think our kids are tired of hearing they are last, and I don't think that type of reinforcement creates progress or confidence in our kids." She reiterated that the bonds could only be used for specific things but added her gratefulness to the constituents for their trust. The time had come for them to follow through on those projects. If it sounds like their minds have been made up. They have for following through on promises made. They had been contemplating other options for years and will not be closing the door on opportunity, but they have to move forward. Diaz said they had been happy to meet with constituents and appreciated the feedback. "We don't want you to think we are not hearing what is being said but our priorities are the kids."
Diaz said academics would be a priority, but building a kid would not just be about tests. "We have to take tests seriously but building a kid is not just about tests." She spoke for some time about tests, curriculum, data and how they engage the kids.
Concerning the field issues, Diaz said they have still been engaged in conversation concerning the Benny Altamirano Sports Complex. "We have not given up." The kids need a facility they can be proud of, allowing them to belong. She again thanked Beck for her time volunteered to help the kids prepare for the SAT exams.
Diaz wanted to extend her heartfelt prayers to the Granado family for their loss of Aiden. Being a small town this will be a loss felt by the entire community.
She came back to the presentation by McGee on classroom disruption. She thought that had been seen more and more since covid—The consequence loss of time and social engagement while quarantined. "We were doing the best we could during that time, and no one is wanting to use covid as an excuse."
Everyone on the board and attending cares about kids and Diaz appreciated everyone's time. "I really have a hard time with hearing that we grudgingly pay our property taxes." She didn't want that message to go to the kids. "We are paying our property taxes and providing our investment in the kids."
Diaz ended with encouraging people to be vaccinated. She knew people had different thoughts and understood their right to choose. "If you are sick, please wear a mask, take precautions, do not spread the wealth. The newest covid and flu vaccines are out."
Cohn said going after Montenegro and Diaz has always been tough. He said he would be positive this time. He thanked them for bringing up New Mexico being 50th in the nation. He had recently attended the New Mexico School Board Association and had been able to talk with other school board members in other states. Those other states wanted to know what New Mexico had been doing and took notes. The other states want to know and that didn't jive with what he has been told. He would mention the Ron Clark Academy, and they didn't even know what that was. He questioned again if the other states want to know what "we are doing why would New Mexico be last?"
Cohn thanked the teachers and staff for making the festivities for Halloween memorable. He added his heartfelt condolences to the Granado family.
Cohn said tax bills would be sent out at the end of the month. "I hope a lot of people are nicer this year." He added if people had questions about their tax bill to contact him.
McMillan appreciated the comment from fellow board members and dialogue with the community and constituents. "I think it has been healthy." He has been here through a few administrations, and the current has provided them with information early before a decision has to be made. It was nice to have the time to investigate from all angles. They have had time to have honest discussions and feedback. He wished everyone a safe and happy Halloween.
Klements conveyed her prayers and wishes to the Granado and Misquez families through their loss. It has been felt throughout the community. She thanked the community members that had come and met with them. "This is not a decision I take lightly." She felt they all had conveyed the seriousness of the decision. She wanted to look into some other information and questions.
She addressed the presentation provided by the La Plata Middle School student council. She has liked them every time and enjoyed them. "They were fun and engaged. They dove into what was working and opportunities." Klement encouraged everyone to vote.
Public comments
Beck thanked the board for the kind words in reference to the SAT preparation for the students. She said her husband takes time off work to come help and added that Mr. and Mrs. Perkins had been helping.
She had an opinion on the fields because she has been the soccer coach. She 100 percent preferred grass. If they fall grass would be better. She had seen bad turf burn when they played on artificial turf. They had attended the World Cup, and the grass had been very nice. The fields in the current condition have not been safe and went over the problems and some of the injuries. They have had referees come and not be happy with the condition of the field. The team has had to play on other fields sometimes. She had worries about moving them to the high school but worried about when they would be able to practice.
Betsy Mullin said she is the mother of three boys and two had graduated from Silver High School and the other in Hobbs. "I will always vote yes on school bond elections because they are of critical importance. I feel like I was duped on the last one not knowing that there would be this supposed planned $6 million expenditure on artificial turf. It has taken me by surprise." She thanked them for the continual discussion. Her sister had said years ago anyone could have a good education anywhere if someone puts their mind to it but found it unfortunate that New Mexico has been at the bottom. Three of her kids had attended New Mexico State University, graduated and have been successful. She did add family support makes a difference in education. "If only there was a way to educate parents so they could educate their children." She said the kids that had presented that night did an amazing job. She hoped that the monies that she had voted for would be properly spent.
Neil McDonald thanked the board for their time and effort they made to make sure the kids have the best education possible. He acknowledged that Hawkins has been all in and had no doubt. He apologized for not reaching out in the past week, as he had a few family issues that took precedence.
He said people come to him, and he has invested in being a fiduciary of the community. People come to him with trust and confidentiality. He takes these duties very seriously.
He knew the funds could not be allocated to other places. Fowler Construction had come out to the Benny Altamirano Sports Complex to see what needed to be fixed and the cost. They said it all had to do with drainage problems. They could fix these problems without replacing the field for $300,000. Turf would still be needed. With that replacement it would total $400,000. All could be done for $1 million which would be 17 percent of the $6 million. They could make even more upgrades for considerably less than the proposed $6 million.
McDonald continued to address the cost of artificial turf, a petroleum based product with a life of 8-10 years. The higher the elevation and higher UV rays will lessen its time. In 8-10 years, it will have to be replaced and the old will need to go to the landfill and would be an ongoing cost to the public. He had talked to the coaches and 80 percent preferred grass, and it had been because of safety.
Walter Woodward started with grass would be safer. The NFL had done a study and artificial turf resulted in 28 percent more lower body injuries, knee injuries 32 percent higher and ankle injuries 69 percent higher. He had played four years of football in high school on artificial turf that resulted in many lasting injuries.
Action items
Consent agenda
The board approved all requests made by Michelle McCain, finance director. She had checks totaling $3,606,371.69, and budget adjustments, and she explained all in depth.
Donations included the Elks Lodge, Silver High School boys soccer, $1,000
Antonio Andazola, maintenance and transportation director, had a revised contract for Montoya for rental fees in the amount of $146,740. They have four new buses. Hawkins wanted to remind them how the funding works from the state for the buses. Andazola went on to explain further how the funding works, and it does increase the awards to the district to pay the additional rental on new buses. The conversation went to the problems with students being tardy due to the buses being late. They have been working through the issues, and it has been improving and some changes that could help. The consolidation had been part of the issues to work through.
The board approved the updated contract with Montoya Transportation.
Public comments none currently.
The next meeting for the finance committee will be November 12 , 2026
The next work session and regular meeting will be November 16 , 2026 (meeting will be in Cliff).
Adjourned



